Below is a compilation of cases organized by court, date, issue, and holding. This is provided for informational purposes only, to assist in conducting case law research. This is obviously not a comprehensive collection. (Key: “SJ = summary judgment; “12(b)(6)” refers to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), under which a court may dismiss a complaint for failure to state a claim.)
Citation Court Date Issue/Claim Favoring Holding
Kwan v. Andalex Group CA2 Dec. 16, 2013 Retaliation P Vacate SJ/D
Graves v. Deutsche Bank (Summary Order) CA2 Dec. 4, 2013 Age Discrimination (ADEA, NYCHRL) D Affirm Grant SJ/D
Holtz v. Rockefeller & Co., Inc., 258 F.3d 62 (2d Cir. 2001) CA2 July 10, 2001 Hostile Work Environment (Sexual Harassment) P Vacate SJ/D
Ferris v. Delta Air Lines, Inc., 277 F.3d 128 (2d Cir. Dec. 21, 2001) CA2 Dec. 21, 2001 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment (Title VII, NYSHRL, NYCHRL) P Vacate SJ/D
Graves v. Deutsche Bank (Summary Order) CA2 Dec. 4, 2013 Retaliation (ADEA, NYCHRL) D Affirm Grant SJ/D
Sandvik v. Sears Holding, 12-cv-2096 EDNY Jan. 2, 2014 Age Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Dall v St Catherine of Siena Medical Center EDNY (Brodie) Aug. 14, 2013 Retaliation D Grant SJ/D
Dall v St Catherine of Siena Medical Center EDNY (Brodie) Aug. 14, 2013 Gender Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Dall v St Catherine of Siena Medical Center EDNY (Brodie) Aug. 14, 2013 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment D Grant SJ/D
Dall v St Catherine of Siena Medical Center EDNY (Brodie) Aug. 14, 2013 Constructive Discharge P Deny SJ/D
Peralta v. Roros 940, Inc., 72 F. Supp. 3d 385 (E.D.N.Y. 2014) EDNY (Gershon) Dec. 10, 2014 Pregnancy Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Domenech v. NYC Employees' Retirement System, 15-cv-2521 (EDNY May 9, 2016) EDNY (Glasser) May 9, 2016 Retaliation P Deny 12(b)(6)/D
Apicella v. Rite Aid EDNY (Kuntz) March 27, 2013 Gender Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Smith v. Town of Hempstead Dept. of Sanitation Sanitary District No. 2 EDNY (Spatt) Nov. 16, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII) P Deny Reconsideration of Denial of SJ/D
Kemp v. CSX Transportation NDNY (Hurd) Jan. 27, 2014 Hostile Work Environment (Race) P Deny SJ/D
Kemp v. CSX Transportation NDNY (Hurd) Jan. 27, 2014 Race Discrimination (1981) P Deny SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment (Title VII) P Deny SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Gender Discrimination/Disparate Treatment (Title VII) P Deny SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Pregnancy Discrimination (Title VII/PDA) P Deny SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Disparate Impact (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII) P Deny SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Gender Discrimination/Disparate Treatment (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Gender Discrimination/Disparate Treatment (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Gender Discrimination/Disparate Treatment (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Meadors v. Ulster County NDNY (Scullin) Nov. 21, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Magdo v. Fidessa Corp. NY Sup NY Jan. 3, 2014 Gender/Pregnancy Discrimination (NYCHRL) P Deny SJ/D
Kulaya v. Dunbar Armored, Inc. NYAD(2) Oct. 9, 2013 Disability Discrimination D Affirm SJ/D
Sacks v. Gandhi Engineering, Inc. SDNY Feb. 27, 2014 Religious Discrimination D Grant SJ/D
Sacks v. Gandhi Engineering, Inc. SDNY Feb. 27, 2014 Disability Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Sacks v. Gandhi Engineering, Inc. SDNY Feb. 27, 2014 Age Discrimination D Grant SJ/D
Colon v. Fashion Institute of Technology SDNY (Baer) Oct. 18, 2013 Race Discrimination (1981) D Grant SJ/D
Litzman v. City of New York SDNY (Baer) Nov. 15, 2013 Religious Discrimination - Failure to Accommodate (Title VII) D Grant SJ/D
Litzman v. City of New York SDNY (Baer) Nov. 15, 2013 Religious Discrimination - Failure to Accommodate (NYCHRL) P Grant SJ/P
Colon v. Fashion Institute of Technology SDNY (Baer) Oct. 18, 2013 Retaliation (1981) D Grant SJ/D
Colon v. Fashion Institute of Technology SDNY (Baer) Oct. 18, 2013 FMLA Interference P Deny SJ/D
Colon v. Fashion Institute of Technology SDNY (Baer) Oct. 18, 2013 FMLA Retaliation P Deny SJ/D
Colon v. Fashion Institute of Technology SDNY (Baer) Oct. 18, 2013 Hostile Work Environment (Race/National Origin) (42 USC 1981, NYCHRL) D Grant SJ/D
Stathatos v. Gala Resources, LLC SDNY (Carter) May 21, 2010 Gender Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Stathatos v. Gala Resources, LLC SDNY (Carter) May 21, 2010 Race Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Stathatos v. Gala Resources, LLC SDNY (Carter) May 21, 2010 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment P Deny SJ/D
Benussi v. UBS Financial Services SDNY (Crotty) Feb. 13, 2014 Retaliation P Deny SJ/D
Benussi v. UBS Financial Services SDNY (Crotty) Feb. 13, 2014 Sexual Orientation Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Idlisan v. New York City Health and Hospitals Corp., 2013 WL 6049076 (SDNY Nov. 15, 2013) SDNY (Engelmayer) Nov. 15, 2013 Disability Discrimination (ADA) D Grant 12(b)(6) Motion to DIsmiss
Brown v. City of New York, 11-cv-2915, 2013 WL 3789091 (SDNY July 19, 2013) SDNY (Engelmayer) July 19, 2013 Retaliation D Grant SJ/D
Brown v. City of New York, 11-cv-2915, 2013 WL 3789091 (SDNY July 19, 2013) SDNY (Engelmayer) July 19, 2013 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment - Vicarious Liability P Deny SJ/D
Brown v. City of New York, 11-cv-2915, 2013 WL 3789091 (SDNY July 19, 2013) SDNY (Engelmayer) July 19, 2013 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment P Deny SJ/D
Pryor v. Jaffe & Asher SDNY (Failla) Jan. 15, 2014 Hostile Work Environment (NYCHRL) P Deny 12(b)(6)
Pryor v. Jaffe & Asher SDNY (Failla) Jan. 15, 2014 Constructive Discharge (NYSHRL, NYCHRL) P Deny 12(b)(6)
Pryor v. Jaffe & Asher SDNY (Failla) Jan. 15, 2014 Hostile Work Environment (NYSHRL) P Deny 12(b)(6)
Najjar v. Mirecki SDNY (Forrest) July 2, 2013 Age Discrimination (NYCHRL) P Deny SJ/D
Najjar v. Mirecki SDNY (Forrest) July 2, 2013 Disability Discrimination (ADA, NYSHRL, NYCHRL) P Deny SJ/D
Najjar v. Mirecki SDNY (Forrest) July 2, 2013 Age Discrimination (ADEA, NYSHRL) D Grant SJ/D
Kassman v. KPMG LLP, 925 F.Supp.2d 453 (SDNY 2013) SDNY (Furman) Feb. 7, 2013 Constructive Discharge P Deny 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss; Plaintiff Stated Claim
O'Diah v. Yogo Oasis SDNY (Maas) July 22, 2013 Race/Color Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
O'Diah v. Yogo Oasis SDNY (Maas) July 22, 2013 National Origin Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Noon v. IBM SDNY (McMahon) Dec. 11, 2013 Failure to Accommodate Disability (ADA) P Deny SJ/D
Noon v. IBM SDNY (McMahon) Dec. 11, 2013 Retaliation (ADA) P Deny SJ/D
Noon v. IBM SDNY (McMahon) Dec. 11, 2013 Disability Discrimination (ADA) P Deny SJ/D
Arty v. NYC Health & Hosp. Corp. SDNY (Nathan) Dec. 3, 2013 Race Discrimination D Grant SJ/D
Viruet v. Port Jervis City School Dist. SDNY (Ramos) Aug. 13, 2013 Race/Color Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Viruet v. Port Jervis City School Dist. SDNY (Ramos) Aug. 13, 2013 National Origin Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Benyard v. White Plains Hosp. Med. Ctr. SDNY (Roman) Nov. 12, 2013 Age Discrimination (Disparate Treatment) (ADEA, NYSHRL) D Grant SJ/D
Benyard v. White Plains Hosp. Med. Ctr. SDNY (Roman) Nov. 12, 2013 Age Discrimination (Disparate Impact) (ADEA, NYSHRL) D Grant SJ/D
Benyard v. White Plains Hosp. Med. Ctr. SDNY (Roman) Nov. 12, 2013 Retaliation (ADEA, NYSHRL) D Grant SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Race/National Origin Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Individual Liability P Deny SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Retaliation P Deny SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Single Employment D Grant SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Hostile Work Environment/Sexual Harassment P Deny SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Joint Employment D Grant SJ/D
Guzman v. NY Post SDNY (Schofield) Oct. 28, 2013 Hostile Work Environment (Race/National Origin) P Deny SJ/D
Smith v. County of Sullivan SDNY (Smith) May 25, 2007 Race Discrimination P Deny SJ/D
Smith v. County of Sullivan SDNY (Smith) May 25, 2007 Retaliation D Grant SJ/D
Smith v. County of Sullivan SDNY (Smith) May 25, 2007 Constructive Discharge P Deny SJ/D
Stoler v. Institute For Integrative Nutrition SDNY (Sweet) Nov. 18, 2013 FMLA Interference P Deny 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss; Plaintiff Stated Claim
Hird-Moorhouse v. Belgian Mission to the United Nations, 2010 WL 3910742 (SDNY Oct. 5, 2010) SDNY (Sweet) Oct. 5, 2010 Age Discrimination (ADEA, NYSHRL, NYCHRL) P Deny SJ/D
Stoler v. Institute For Integrative Nutrition SDNY (Sweet) Nov. 18, 2013 Retaliation (Title VII, NYCHRL) P Deny 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss; Plaintiff Stated Claim
Stoler v. Institute For Integrative Nutrition SDNY (Sweet) Nov. 18, 2013 Constructive Discharge/FMLA Interference P Deny 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss; Plaintiff Stated Claim
Stoler v. Institute For Integrative Nutrition SDNY (Sweet) Nov. 18, 2013 FMLA Retaliation P Deny 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss; Plaintiff Stated Claim
Glaser v. Gap Inc. SDNY (Zilly) Jan. 30, 2014 Failure to Accommodate Disability P Deny SJ/D
Glaser v. Gap Inc. SDNY (Zilly) Jan. 30, 2014 Disability Discrimination (ADA, NYSHRL) P Deny SJ/D
Wolf v. Time Warner, Inc., 2012 WL 4336232, 09-cv-6549 (SDNY Sept. 17, 2012) SDNY (Sullivan) Sept. 17, 2012 Retaliation D Grant SJ/D
Wolf v. Time Warner, Inc., 2012 WL 4336232, 09-cv-6549 (SDNY Sept. 17, 2012) SDNY (Sullivan) Sept. 17, 2012 Age Discrimination (ADEA, NYCHRL) D Grant SJ/D